Problematic
The problem is that there is currently no good control for access to the Orizaba Technological Institute (ITO).
Tecnológico de Orizaba (ITO).
This is because the security guards who are currently at the entrance have a security system which is simply based on asking to show the credential.
Due to the large number of students who attend the institution, they only look at it and do not verify that they are really a student of said institution, neglecting security, which is the main reason for having these rules.
For this problem, 10 possible solutions will be determined.
Said solutions will be arranged in a comparative table in which the points for and against will be marked, so that they are evaluated and thus, determine the best possible solution.
Problem Solution Box.
|
Possible solution |
Points in favor |
Points Against |
|
By designating a password |
A fully automatic system would be used leaving behind the use of a security guard. | The password could be used by people outside the institution
The equipment can deteriorate since the contact of those who make use of it is needed. |
|
Fingerprint access control |
It offers a lot of security because you have to be in the database to be able to enter
The equipment is fully automatic It is quick to use |
Equipment comes at a great cost
It is a bit fragile, thus being able to deteriorate The database must be renewed every semester |
|
Access control through the ocular iris |
This equipment offers 100% security since it is as if it were a very personal password
It is fully automated It is quick to use |
The team the extremely expensive
The database may not be able to contain the large number of students It is easy to damage It is a bit slow, which is reflected in the large number of students |
|
Admission to the university by control number |
It's quick to enter
There would be order when entering The equipment is inexpensive |
The control number can be learned by outsiders of the institution
It takes staff to be observing Equipment can be damaged |
|
Access via barcode credential |
The code is unique for students
A constant order would be maintained Access is fast The equipment does not have much cost |
Can be cloned
A guard is needed to be watching The laser may not read the codes |
|
Using a smartphone app |
It would be very fast
It is an application that is easy to use There is no contact with the equipment avoiding being damaged The data is personal |
Not all students have a smartphone
The application is very easy to get The system can be fooled |
|
Using a chip credential |
The system would recognize the chip by shaking it to have contact with the user
It is a quick method to enter The process is automated No staff needed |
It is very expensive to buy chips for all students
It's fragile Credentials can be lost, can be found and used for bad purposes Credentials can be borrowed |
|
Control with revolving security doors |
It is very good as it forces the police to observe that it really is the person on the credential
Offers good security The equipment is heavy duty |
The access process is slow
It takes staff to use Income would be very congested |
